bought for my son for a gift, he loves them! super soft inside with a loose but not tooooo loose fit!

They’re comfy, warm but light enough to use as an underlayer at work. 2 issues are the liner rubs off extremely easily. Any clothes underneath get covered in a layer or white threads. Minor issue for me but I can see why someone wouldn’t like that Other issue is much more minor. One nice part is the form fitting ankles. Really good for keeping heat in, I’ve got small ankles but still managed to stretch them out after a week of wear. I got these on clearance, I don’t know if I’d get them at asking price but they’re super comfortable so I wouldn’t write them off either!