Thanks for your feedback, it's super important to us! We totally understand your frustration and we’ll make sure it ends up in the right hands. Sometimes, something as small as a change in fabric treatment and finishing — the ways that jeans get their color or wash — can affect the way a pair of jeans fits or even smells. So can a slight change in the composition of the fabric. Of course, we’re always working to make our fits as consistent as possible, so we'll definitely flag this one. So you know, we have a 60-day return policy if you’re not satisfied with your product. You can always call us at 1-800-872-5384 or start a chat with us in the “Ask Indigo” box on the bottom left of your screen if you’d like further assistance!