I can understand why these shorts are getting mixed reviews. I am typically a size 18/20, and in rigid denim, I will usually size up to a 22 because I like the extra room. However, luckily I bought both 22 and 24 sizes because the reviews seems so mixed in how many sizes you should size up. So, I will say definitely size up from your normal size. The 22s fit ok, they were a little tight in the waist and I feel like when I sit down it gave me major wedgie. But, the 24s were perfect! They sit just right on my waist and I have room to sit down and eat, and the thighs are looser but I like that because I have thick thighs. So, depending on the fit you like, if you want a more fitted fit, I would just size up 1 size, but if you like your shorts to be more breathable with a little room, then size up 2 sizes. The shorts themselves look pretty much like they do on the website and I really love the wash and the rise as well. Personally, I love these!