Overall, I'd give the shirts 4.75 stars. They seem to be very well constructed. Based on how thin some other shirts I’ve bought are, these could easily be considered heavy fabric. The actual thickness of the fabric varies a bit between different colors. I am both big and tall, so it is unheard for me to find good T's for $8-12/ea. There is a paper label around waist high which you will want to cut off, it rustles. The label on the back of the neck is printed on the shirt, so nothing to rustle or scratch there. Content: Of the shirts I have, content varies by color. 100% cotton - Chocolate, Dark Navy, Dark Olive, English Red, Heather Green, Lincoln Green, Orange, Royal Blue. 99% cotton, 1% polyester - Ash Grey 90% cotton, 10% polyester - Heather Grey Made in: Nicaragua and Mexico. There is a slight variation in the cuts of the different colored shirts. Some are a little roomier than others. The label recommends washing in cold. I HIGHLY recommend washing in cold. The shirts tend to shrink a little the first couple times they are washed. I always wash mine in cold and hang them up to dry, but still had that little bit of shrinkage. The most comfortable: Dark Navy and Black Olive. They started out very roomy and even after a bit of shrinkage are still quite comfortable. Chocolate and Lincoln Green just barely still fit. Desert Sand started out ok, but after two washings it had shrunk enough that it is a little small. I find I'm yanking on it to stretch it.